In the NBA Playoffs, stars shine—but sharp bettors know the real value often lies in the margins. Prop bets can be goldmines when you understand player roles, usage, and how playoff matchups shift night to night. With momentum surging and rotations tightening, it’s the perfect time to isolate edges and stack smart wagers.
Consistency is key in postseason betting, and that means reading the rhythm of each series. Player props give us a unique way to capitalize on matchups that the books can’t always price accurately. Yesterday, we leaned on role players and delivered another profitable night. Let’s recap and then dive into today’s top edges.
Recap: May 22, 2025
We went 2-for-3 on our prop plays:
✅ Alex Caruso Over 7.5 Points – Cash it. He dropped 9.
✅ Isaiah Hartenstein Over 7.5 Rebounds – Easy winner with 8 boards.
❌ Julius Randle Over 24.5 Points + Assists – Rough night, he finished with just 11.
Still a profitable night—and we’re aiming to keep it rolling.
Top NBA Prop Picks for May 23, 2025
🔹 Josh Hart UNDER 12.5 Points vs Indiana Pacers
He’s hit the under in 4 of his last 5 games, and while he’s averaging 13.6 PPG this season, the playoff intensity and Indiana’s defensive pressure make this a solid fade spot.
🔹 Miles McBride OVER 4.5 Points vs Indiana Pacers
He’s been consistent—clearing this number in 5 straight games and averaging 9.5 PPG. As the Knicks tighten rotations, he’s earning trust and taking smart shots.
🔹 Obi Toppin OVER 12.5 Points + Rebounds + Assists @ New York Knicks
He’s over that number in just 2 of his last 5, but he’s averaging 16.1 PRA. In a high-energy game where depth matters, expect Toppin to show up and contribute across the board.
Final Thoughts:
These NBA prop bets are based on clear trends and matchup value. Whether you’re riding with us on PrizePicks, FanDuel, DraftKings, BetMGM, or Underdog, these are smart angles heading into tonight’s action. Bet with discipline, manage your bankroll, and enjoy the show. Let’s cash out!
